How to End a Lease Early by Mutual Agreement in Vermont: A Tenant’s Guide

In Vermont, breaking a lease can be risky, but tenants have a significant legal safety net that does not exist in every state: the Duty to Mitigate Damages. Vermont courts have established that if a tenant abandons a property, the landlord generally cannot simply let it sit empty and sue for the remaining rent; they must make a reasonable effort to find a new tenant.

However, relying on a judge to decide if your landlord tried "hard enough" to re-rent the unit is stressful and uncertain. The safest, most definitive way to end your liability is through a Mutual Agreement to Terminate Tenancy.

Unlike termination for cause (like non-payment), there is no official "Form" on the Vermont Judiciary website for a mutual agreement. It is a private contract between you and your landlord. This guide explains how to draft one, how to leverage Vermont’s mitigation laws, and strict timelines for security deposits.

How a Mutual Agreement Works in Vermont

A mutual agreement is a voluntary contract where the landlord and tenant agree to end the lease on a specific date, releasing the tenant from future liability.

• No "Official" State Form: Vermont does not have a government-mandated form for mutual lease termination. While there are strict forms for eviction notices (like the 14-day notice for non-payment), a mutual ending is handled through a written agreement signed by both parties.

• Overrides the Lease: A valid mutual agreement replaces the expiration date of your original lease. It legally stops your obligation to pay rent after the agreed move-out date.

• Voluntary: Neither party can be forced to sign this. If a landlord wants to evict you, they must have legal grounds (like breach of lease) and provide the proper 30-day or 14-day actual notice.

When Should You Use It?

1. Breaking a Fixed-Term Lease

If you need to leave for a job or family emergency, simply giving notice is often not enough to end your financial obligation under a fixed-term lease.

• The "Mitigation" Leverage: Under Vermont case law (O'Brien v. Black), landlords have a duty to mitigate damages.

• The Strategy: You can propose a mutual agreement to your landlord: "I need to vacate early. Since you have a duty to re-rent the unit anyway, I propose we sign a mutual agreement where I pay rent through [Date] and you release me from the remainder of the lease." This gives the landlord certainty and guaranteed rent while they look for a new tenant.

2. "Cash for Keys" (Sale of Property)

In Vermont, if a landlord sells a building, the new owner generally takes the property subject to existing leases. They cannot kick you out just because they bought the building unless the lease specifically allows it or you are month-to-month and they give proper notice (often 30–90 days depending on tenure).

• The Negotiation: If a landlord wants to sell the home empty, they may offer you "Cash for Keys." This is a legal, private agreement where they pay you to leave early.

• Is it Legal? Yes. It is fully legal in Vermont as long as it is voluntary, in writing, and not coerced.

How to Draft the Agreement

Since there is no standard government form, you must draft a letter. It must be clear to be enforceable.

Required Elements:

1. Title: "Mutual Termination of Lease Agreement."

2. Parties: Full names of the Landlord and Tenant.

3. Property: The complete address of the rental unit.

4. Termination Date: The specific date and time you will vacate.

5. Release of Liability: A clause stating: "The Landlord releases the Tenant from all future obligations under the lease, including rent, after the Termination Date."

6. Security Deposit: Explicitly reference the 14-day return rule (see below) to ensure there is no confusion.

7. Signatures: Both parties must sign and date the document.

The Risks for Tenants

1. The 14-Day Security Deposit Rule

Vermont has one of the fastest security deposit return windows in the country. Under 9 V.S.A. § 4461, landlords must return your deposit (with an itemized list of deductions) within 14 days of you moving out.

• The Trap: If you leave early without a written agreement, the landlord might claim you "abandoned" the unit and that the lease hasn't ended, potentially delaying this 14-day clock. A mutual agreement sets a firm "move-out date" that triggers the deadline.

2. Implied Warranty of Habitability

If you are leaving because the unit is unsafe (no heat, water, etc.), do not just sign a mutual agreement that waives your rights. Under 9 V.S.A. § 4458, if a landlord fails to make repairs within a reasonable time after receiving notice, you may have the right to terminate the lease and sue for damages. A simple mutual agreement might prevent you from claiming those damages later.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Is there an official Vermont form to end a lease?

No. While the state provides templates for some notices, there is no mandated form for mutual termination. You must write your own contract.

2. Can I break my lease for domestic violence?

Yes. Under 9 V.S.A. § 4472, "protected tenants" (victims of abuse, sexual assault, or stalking) can terminate a lease early. You must provide the landlord with 30 days' written notice and documentation (like a relief from abuse order or police report). You do not need the landlord's permission or a mutual agreement for this.

3. Does the landlord have to find a new tenant if I move out?

Yes. Vermont law generally imposes a "duty to mitigate," meaning the landlord must make reasonable efforts to re-rent the apartment rather than letting damages pile up. This applies to both commercial and residential leases based on court precedents.

4. When do I get my deposit back?

The landlord has 14 days from the date you vacate to return your deposit. If they miss this deadline, they may forfeit the right to withhold any of it. If the failure is willful, you can sue for double the amount.

5. How much notice do I need to give if I am month-to-month?

Under 9 V.S.A. § 4456(d), tenants generally must give notice at least one rental payment period (usually 30 days/1 month) prior to the termination date, unless the lease says otherwise.

References:

• 9 V.S.A. § 4467 (Termination of tenancy; notice)

• 9 V.S.A. § 4461 (Security deposits)

• 9 V.S.A. § 4472 (Right to terminate; domestic violence)

• O'Brien v. Black, 162 Vt. 448 (1994) (Duty to Mitigate)

• CVOEO: Notice Periods

Source: www.dv.support

LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/dvsupportofficial